Thursday, 30 May 2013

How Free is Our Speech? - Radio 4 Discussion

Clive Anderson recently chaired a discussion on Radio 4 that asked a simple question: how free is our speech in Britain today? The discussion also took the time to considered specifically how speech on social media should be controlled or otherwise.

Billed as 'the programme that gets behind the legal issues of the day,' it certainly did that. You can listen to the episode in full here.

Clive Anderson kicked things off with a nice overview of the legal history as it exists in law in Britain to date and how this contrasts with our love of freedom:

"We live in a free country where the right to speak out mind is fundamental to our liberty and vital to our democracy. Developed under the common law, freedom of thought and expression are nowadays protected by the ECHR and recognised in Other international declarations.

In theory we're entitled to say what we like, even if others don't like what we say. Well in practice there has always been plenty of restrictions of what can be uttered in public or published in print. Through the centuries laws against blasphemy, libel, pornography and sedition have been deployed to keep private thoughts out of the public eye. Tv and theatre shows have been subject to censorship and control. 
But what of freedom of expression today? 
Do new laws to prevent hate speech and to protect individuals and minority groups from offence and victimisation have the effect intended or otherwise of inhibiting free speech? Is the criminal law the right weapon to use against those who are disrespectful of other races, religions or sexual preferences? 
Is it useful to prosecute a demonstrator who said to DC that he had blood on this hands? Is it really grounds for arrest to suggest that a police horse is gay? In what circumstances is it against the law to use social media to make anti-social remarks? Is it really a police man's lot to police which jokes are liable to cause offence? Is out wish to be tolerant of minorities making us intolerant of free speech?
It's important to say at this point that Clive Anderson was joined by barrister Ivan hare (his chamber's write-up on the episode here), Barrister Neil Addison and Chief Constable Andrew Trotter. Also Gavin Phillipson, a professor of law at Durham University.


Clive Anderson again:
"So is free speech a fundamental right that still exists of a luxury that has to be compromised in the interest of public order? 
Rowan Atkinson has spoken of a "creeping culture of censoriousness". That we're accepting the criminalisation of speech that offends, insults or disparages. Is Mr Atkinson onto something?

Ivan Hare responded:
"Yes increasing number of groups are now protected from speech that might be regarded as inciting hatred against them. Race hatred law was introduced in the 1960s; and more recently, laws against religious hatred were introduced as well as laws against the incitement to hatred against sexual orientation hatred."
Neil Addison disputed comments that came from Andrew Trotter, saying that it is the job of the police to protect people from danger that may harm them, not from comments and opinions they may disagree with.

Gavin Phillipson came into the debate and said that the Public Order offences are very broad. While section 29 (j) which gives reasons why you can't prosecute somebody are tucked away and hard to find.

Ivan Hare said that while laws against religious and sexual discrimination - you have to insult the person not the religion to be prosecuted (free speech clause) - are narrower, they are also less coherent. As in: you choose your religion whereas people argue that you don't choose your sexual orientation. While religious groups would say they didn't choose they religious orientation either.

Neil Addison in Liverpool said that he would question the need for the race hatred legislation or that on sexual orientation. Because it is about words or language that "are likely" to stir up hatred. But hatred is an emotion, not an action. Should the law be involved in stuff that involved emotion? It's different if your inciting people against another person's race of sexual orientation - the law must stop that - but should it be involved in something that at best may incite an emotion, not incite an action?

Gavin Phillipson countered this by saying hate law is there to reassure vulnerable communities.

Neil Addison said that hate laws are there to stop people disagreeing with government policies and trends in society. Adding that the danger is that law in itself is acting as a censor and the police then becomes the enforcers of the prevailing orthodoxy rather than keepers of the peace.


Clive Anderson again:
"This goes to the heart of the discussion: is the hate law a censorship measure stopping people from expressing themselves?"

Andrew Trotter: If someone is spouting hate speech and there is likelihood of violence, and even if there isn't - if you have a vulnerable person being berated for their race I think it's quite correct that people give up rights to the state and they expect protection from the state.

Mr Trotter then said something which I thought very important and very true and applicable to use all:
"This isn't a dry academic subject. This is real. This is something that happens everyday."

One of the great improvements we've seen in society is that people are much more conscious of the sensitivities of others. There were no good old days when we said what we felt like. We're a far more civilised society now I think because of some of these measures.

----- Would that not be covered by the more general public order law? Section 5? Without having to specify race or sexuality?

Barrister points out that selecting one of the protected groups is an aggravating factor under public order law.

Gavin agreed with much that Trotter said - added that need to draw a line between face to face words - those likely to cause a fight - assaultive words and speech directed to public at large - such as blog and newspaper. This second area if where the real free speech concerns are.

Neil Anderson replied to trotter: you didn't need religious hatred law to stop somebody abusing somebody on transport or in the public area. That's always been illegal.

We're in risk of heading towards a hate crime arms race where one group says they're not protected, another group complains and so on. Instead of the basics that law should protect everyone equally.

Trotter said the exacting standards have made us a more tolerant society.

Addison countered by using example of Christian preacher arrested.

------

Is the law too complicated?

Simon Calvert from Christian institute has said that large number of Christians have been arrested and prosecuted for saying things that are unfashionable - not that which incites or cause hatred.

How can simply expressing support for traditional marriage be a hate crime? Reinforces addison's point.

DPP v Hamon was charged under section 5 which was broader as sexual hate speech allows speaker to say acts etc are wrong. The Statute has defences included within to allow traditional Christian preaching and so on.


Trotter: I can't and won't defend some of the examples raised.

-----

I use the positive example of the director of the DPP who has put out very strong guidance about the high threshold that exists before people police even look at the case.

And I think that sort of approach where we don't get involved in the issues unless it is an absolutely serious matter.

Hare countered Gavin by saying Hamond case predated sexual hatred law and said because he said it was immoral, and therefore referring directly to the person, the narrower hate law could have caught him


Philip Pritchard was singing anti-English songs

Petra mills found to have abused Australian neighbour Chelsea o'reilly by calling her a stupid, fat Australian.


CA rightly noted that section 5 is due to be removed from law. Trotter welcomed the removal.

Trotter questioned wisdom of Original officer, custody officer and then CPS when Sam was prosecuted for calling a police horse gay.

Ivan hare said hate speech is too paternalistic and takes away from the autonomy of the audience who should be able to make their own decision - as was the intention of free speech protection which gives meaning to the market for ideas.

Usually by exposing ideas of hatred to discussion you reveal how foolish they are.

Addison agreed entirely and added that John Stuart mill said that if the whole world was of one opinion and only one person disagreed, the whole world would not be justified in silencing that one person.

Added: "good arguments drive out bad arguments"

Trotter: "There is something about context, common sense and discretion"

There is a role for us to step in at the extreme end of these comments in order to protect people. Don't step in too quickly, exercise good judgement and use the HRA as a good measure to ensure a proportionate response and not thinking we have to investigate every allegation which I think is a common mistake.

CA - in Manchester they're recording attacks on goths, emos and other similar types of youth culture. Literally fashion police; exhib again extends the categories of people who are seen as needing extra protection.

Trotter: more a demonstration of support to that community after criticisms of antipathy in the past.


Addison: the law should deal with crimes equally.

-------

Social media

Plenty of examples that have hit headlines - Paul chambers charged with menacing electronic application.

Was identified as joke but didnt stop police, CPS and court of first instance

Trotter: I find it completely inexplicable. All the way through people seem to recognise this wasn't terribly real and yet it still had a life of its own and I do find it quite extraordinary. It should have stopped at first instance, it should never have got past the police, it should never have gone to the CPS and the CPS shouldn't have run it either.

It is really difficult to understand; looking back on that case how we got into that position. I don't think anyone can defend what happened there.

CA - should we watch what people are doing on Twitter?

We have to accept that people use different methods of communicating than was the case in the past. And people will use social media to contribute to the kind of public discussions of general importance that we say are so important that they should be defended.

Essentially the difficulty is that a legal regime that was intended to govern broadcasting and in particular the broadcasting of offensive material is simply being applied to other forms media which aren't broadcasting in the same sense as those for which the communications act or previously the broadcasting act were passed to resolve.

Gavin would leave sexual and racial hatred law on statute book. Remove section 5 - shouldn't have police censoring political speech on streets and would remove provisions in the malicious communications act that prohibit grossly offensive comments on Twitter because it is far to uncertain and subjective.


CA- Do we need more guidance?

Gavin said we have been given terribly uncertain laws that contain words like grossly offensive that noone really knows what that means and different people find different things grossly offensive. And it's up to them to make decisions on that and no wonder they make mistakes some times because they're given an impossible job.

How would you rearrange law to make it easier for police and citizens?

Trotter: I take the view that DDP guidance is really useful. But obviously still issues. But requirement for high threshold and a clear public interest is really good and should be applicable beyond social media. Into section 5 without losing its real use to us: as a Friday night tool to deal with disorder on the street.


I don't think we should go into these other arenas at all. It's not for us to be policing political views on behalf of people who are offended. It's only for us to deal with a real issue where people are being victimised, harassed, threatened. It's given very clear guidance to police forces to apply very very high threshold to these things before we even start looking at them.

Neil Addison:

I would get rid of racial and sexual orientation hatred laws completely so the law is equal to all.

As far as the communications act: I would say directed at another so we're not policing something that someone has said on twitter generally then take offence to.

Ivan hare:

We need to abolish section 5 and repeal the incitement to hatred provision. Where I disagree with Neil Addison is in relation to hate crime - I think you can draw distinction where someone has chosen someone on grounds of race - because it it right to punish that more seriously.

4 experts and 4 completely different view on how to reform the system.




104 comments:

  1. I want to say thank to you people for this great and helpful info. Thanks!!!
    ny criminal lawyers

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm confident that once you read this again you come to read these articles and blogs. bubblegum casting reviews

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thankfulness to my dad who informed me relating to this blog, this website is really amazing. criminal attorney ny

    ReplyDelete
  4. It’s an outstanding article in favor of all the web guests; they will get benefit from it I am confident. check over here

    ReplyDelete
  5. It’s never too late to develop your data and your contents really excite me a lot.
    useful link

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you so much for such a great blog.check my source

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great blogs buddy……… this will definitely assist me.
    repair credit

    ReplyDelete
  8. congratulations guys, quality information you have given!!! phlebotomy training

    ReplyDelete
  9. It’s amazing to visit again n again coming to your blogs the superb effort is here. sky blue credit reivews

    ReplyDelete
  10. I love all details that you give in your articles.

    Best Electric Shaver

    ReplyDelete
  11. Your blogs and its stuff are so notable and worthwhile it can make me return. Philips Norelco 1160x Review

    ReplyDelete
  12. No wonder why you receive countless of feedbacks.

    book online

    ReplyDelete
  13. This blog is further than my expectations. Nice work guys!!!how to get jobs

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think I have really come on the right place for getting the perfect info. Kansas City SEO company

    ReplyDelete
  15. Enthralling stuff I haven't been finished particular data in a lasting time.
    Best Electric Shaver For Men

    ReplyDelete
  16. You have shared the best blog. This is what I really need immediately.healthy diet plan

    ReplyDelete
  17. This is really pretty cool place I like it because it has everything I want more on this blog soon.
    cancer symptoms

    ReplyDelete
  18. how to lose man boobsIt's not my very first time to visit this blog; I’m visiting this daily and acquire superb info from here day by day.

    ReplyDelete
  19. These blogs are valuable because these are providing such informative information for all the people.credit repair

    ReplyDelete
  20. Enthralling stuff I haven't been finished particular data in a lasting time.

    best security system

    ReplyDelete
  21. I thought haven’t read such distinctive material anywhere else on-line.
    nutrition

    ReplyDelete
  22. I got this blog site through my friends and when I searched this really there were informative articles at the place. best home security systems

    ReplyDelete
  23. I never ever read such type of info before this was really incredible. web url opener

    ReplyDelete
  24. I’m impressed with the special and informative contents that you just offer in such short timing.

    best security system

    ReplyDelete
  25. This is very essential blog; it helped me a lot whatever you have provided.
    online tutoring

    ReplyDelete
  26. It’s a classic great for me to go to this blog site, it offers helpful suggestions best Braun electric shavers

    ReplyDelete
  27. I was pinning away for such type of blogs, thanks for posting this for us. online payday lenders operating in ky

    ReplyDelete
  28. Found your blog excessively interesting indeed. I really enjoyed studying it.Click Here

    ReplyDelete
  29. I would be supportive on all your articles and blogs as a result of they are simply up to the mark. home security systems

    ReplyDelete
  30. besthomeAmiable articles and the blogs really helped me a lot, thanks for the valuable information.

    ReplyDelete
  31. I’ve been admirer of your website because I have got the great articles here. loans now

    ReplyDelete
  32. Your articles don’t beat about the bushes these are actually exact t to the purpose. best electric shaver blog

    ReplyDelete
  33. You have done really a superb job with your web site. Marvelous stuff is here to read. best remington electric shavers

    ReplyDelete
  34. This is really pretty cool place I like it because it has everything I want more on this blog soon.labiaplasty chicago

    ReplyDelete
  35. The information you have given in the blog really marvelous and more interesting. How to lose belly fat fast

    ReplyDelete
  36. I desire lots of articles and blogs please upload soon.
    hajj visa

    ReplyDelete

  37. lifeshield reviews
    I’m impressed with the special and informative contents that you just offer in such short timing.

    ReplyDelete
  38. This post is really valuable that designed for the new visitors. Pleasing work, keep on writing.
    Beef jerky wholesale

    ReplyDelete
  39. ovation reviews
    Nicest information!!! I'll be enchanted to greatly help due to what I've learnt from here.

    ReplyDelete
  40. select my shaver reviews
    It feels good to feature much enlightening and unique articles on your websites.

    ReplyDelete
  41. braun series 7 790cc pulsonic shaver system review
    Your blogs have allured me a lot. I’ll again visit this great site to get more valuable stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  42. dentist reseda
    No wonder why you receive countless of feedbacks.

    ReplyDelete
  43. NY Medicaid fraud attorney
    It is extremely nice to see the greatest details presented in an easy and understanding manner.

    ReplyDelete
  44. seo agency
    What a great blog it is!!! You are in truth on your way to colossal success. Well done.

    ReplyDelete
  45. compare car insurance rates
    Your contents are too straightforward to browse and easy to understand.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Panda Designs
    I truly get pleasure from while I read your blogs and its content.

    ReplyDelete
  47. who's calling me
    While the admin of the web site is working, no question soon it will likely be famous, due to its feature blogs.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Medical Negligence Claims
    The individuals not reading your blogs stuff are missing out much qualitative contents.

    ReplyDelete
  49. write my essay
    I am surprised why other specialized don’t perceive your site I’m greatly cheerful I discovered this.

    ReplyDelete
  50. These are actually wonderful some ideas in the blog. You have touched good quality points here. In whatever way continue writing. lifestyle fitness

    ReplyDelete
  51. It’s really very informative that I wanted ever, thanks for this. http://www.easyonlinepaydayloan.com

    ReplyDelete
  52. A great job you have already done. I’m really delighted to see your amazing work.
    lifestyle definition

    ReplyDelete
  53. I continuously continue coming to your website once more simply in case you have posted new contents.
    healthy lifestyle

    ReplyDelete
  54. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Your writers are extremely fantastic that have made easy to understand everything for us.
    fashion

    ReplyDelete
  56. Bundles of thanks for providing such kind of blogs with the informative and impressive articles.
    life style

    ReplyDelete
  57. I’m glad to locate so much of informative data in your blog. Visit us at

    ReplyDelete
  58. healthy lifestyle
    I went over this website and I conceive you've got a large number of splendid information,

    ReplyDelete
  59. I am certain this article has touched all the web visitors; it’s very extremely lovely script.
    whole life insurance no physical

    ReplyDelete
  60. Way cool some valid points! I am grateful for you making this post on hand; the rest of this website is also first-class. Have a great fun.
    whole life insurance quotes

    ReplyDelete
  61. I was seeking this convinced info for a long time. Thank you for offering such great information and good luck.
    auto insurance quotes

    ReplyDelete
  62. Thanks for this colossal information, pleasant read!
    latest android phones

    ReplyDelete
  63. You have really selected the suitable topic; this is one of my favorite blogs.
    when does the cost of a 20 year old drivers insurance drop

    ReplyDelete
  64. vitiligo cosmetics
    I am so happy to visit your site; it carries plenty of superb facts that pleased me.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Thanks for the entire information you have given here to impart knowledge amongst us?
    watch

    ReplyDelete
  66. This blog post is really great; the quality information of this post is genuinely incredible.
    easy fast direct payday lenders

    ReplyDelete
  67. Wow! Thanks a lot to you! I always desired to write in my own website something like you have shared.
    whole life ins

    ReplyDelete
  68. Hi to everybody, it’s really good for me to come on this site, it gives obliging Information.
    best sitation service

    ReplyDelete
  69. Wowww! Thanks a lot baby! I always required writing in my site something very special like your blog has. You have really helped me a lot.
    adt review

    ReplyDelete
  70. Your post is really quite important for me. Thanks for this edifying post.
    best home security

    ReplyDelete
  71. Big thanks to you for sharing such great information.
    instagram

    ReplyDelete
  72. I love your post because I like the way you collaborate and share your opinions, great blog, carry on.
    Manual backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  73. Hmmm, Your writing and entertaining style is so awesome, keep it up buddies!
    missouri online payday loan lenders

    ReplyDelete
  74. Wow! Thanks a lot to you! I always desired to write in my own website something like you have shared.
    blind date

    ReplyDelete
  75. This is a really very awesome blog more than ever to those new to blogosphere, concise and perfect information…
    life insurance rates

    ReplyDelete
  76. congratulations guys, quality information you have given!!! infogrphics

    ReplyDelete
  77. I love your post because I like the way you collaborate and share your opinions, great blog, carry on.
    Top Rated Electric Shavers

    ReplyDelete
  78. You have discusses incredible points that sounds good, keep up the great work. Best Electric Shaver 2014

    ReplyDelete
  79. I love the way you write your post. Each and everything is simply perfect. Thanks Hajj packages

    ReplyDelete
  80. I had been looking around the best blogs site and now I’m on the right place, pretty wonderful!! home security systems reviews

    ReplyDelete
  81. I have spent a good time here at your blog reading. Must Keep the ball rolling buddies! Password Manager - LogmeOnce

    ReplyDelete
  82. For a long time me & my friend were searching for informative blogs, but now I am on the right place guys, you have made a room in my hea umrah tours

    ReplyDelete
  83. Hi to everybody, it’s really good for me to come on this site, it gives obliging Information. High PR web 2.0

    ReplyDelete
  84. This is a great post; it was very edifying. I look ahead in reading more of your work.payday loans in new york york ny

    ReplyDelete
  85. This is surely a very good blog, thanks a lot for sharing such nice information here.payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  86. how to build business credit fast
    Have a big thanks to you! It sounds great not only I liked this, but also everybody will appreciate you on your nice efforts.

    ReplyDelete
  87. Good post. I was searching for such type of issues for a long time, now I have got it. Thanks
    cash advance

    ReplyDelete
  88. Thankfulness to my best ever friend who suggested me to visit this blog, it’s beyond doubt miraculous!! payday loans for people with savings account

    ReplyDelete
  89. Fabulous ideas you have still provided to us, anyway this blog is really wonderful for all. life insurance cheap rates

    ReplyDelete
  90. Your all explanations are meaningful in this blog. I love reading this. car insurance

    ReplyDelete
  91. Every blog tells something. This blog is actually fantastic and I’ve got enough things while reading this post. garciniacambogiahowto.com/dr-oz-free-trial-supplements/

    ReplyDelete
  92. I love your blog... Very nice colors & theme as well as the topic you selected is superb, in final words I can say that this is truly great! Health Insurance Fort Lauderdale

    ReplyDelete
  93. Hi, I just desired to give you quick thumbs up on your work, really fantastic blog! low income health insurance florida residents

    ReplyDelete
  94. Well spoken baby. I have got to explore more on this issue as this is really essential content…. healthcare insurance company

    ReplyDelete
  95. Hi buddy! This post is written quite better! Reading throughout this post reminds me of my best friend! I would forward this post to him. oro gold

    ReplyDelete
  96. Sharing such amazing information is really a good idea. I want to appreciate you on this. vine vera reviews

    ReplyDelete
  97. Incredibly nice article, accurately what I was in search of. Thanks vine vera

    ReplyDelete
  98. It’s amazing to visit again n again coming to your blogs the superb effort is here.i need a loan

    ReplyDelete
  99. This is a great post; it was very edifying. I look ahead in reading more of your work.Paul Dansker

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Quote

Why Choose Us?

Incredible Support

There was an error in this gadget